red line SuperKids Software Review - The Parent's and Teacher's Guide to Childrens' Software
free newsletter! spacer tell a friend! spacer contests
  bestseller list
  price survey
  what's new
  product support
educational tools
  ask a scientist
  math worksheets
  vocabulary builders
  iPhone/iPad apps
  logic games
  brain food
educational insights

feature articles
  iPhone/iPad apps
  reading corner
  movie corner
SuperKids home
  about SuperKids
  * * *


  * * *

spacer all reviews > > > music software

The Nutcracker Music Game (v2)

Music Games International

Ages 4 to 104

Rating Scale
5 = great,    1 = poor
Educational Value
Kid Appeal
Ease of Use

Nutcracker Screen Shot arrow indentSystem Requirements

arrow indentPC / Mac Price Survey

arrow indentProduct Support

Wow! Same title, different program! It's not often that the occasionally jaded editors at SuperKids can say that about an updated version of a program they have previously reviewed. But that's what we said when we got a look at the new release of this musical jigsaw puzzle, first reviewed a year ago.

The Nutcracker Music Game is still an innovative, interactive musical education program, built around one of the most popular suites of classical music -- Tchaikovsky's Nutcracker Suite. And it still challenges users to identify the various musical instruments used in familiar classical pieces of music. But unlike its predecessor, it is no longer limited to this single activity.

The new version of The Nutcracker Music Game now includes a challenge/reward theme, wherein the user is challenged to play and solve nine musical games to rescue the Prince who had been turned into the wooden nutcracker. These games range from matching single instruments to the sounds they make, to repeating musical notes on an onscreen vibraphone, to musical trivia. The original core activity of identifying the multiple instruments used in eight different Nutcracker pieces remains, along with a similar activity for Tchaikovsky's Childrens Album.

Educational Value

As with the original version, The Nutcracker Music Game is very helpful to budding young musicians, as well as to those with more of a layperson's interest in music. For those that have never stopped to carefully listen to orchestrated classical music, The Nutcracker Music Game offers a great opportunity to listen and learn. For either, the effect is analagous to a "musical jigsaw puzzle." Instead of trying to recreate that which is seen with the eyes, here the user must attempt to recreate that which is heard with the ears.

The original version fell short, however, in its limited depth and breadth. This version goes a long way toward rectifying those shortcomings, by the inclusion of a variety of educational games, activities, and materials. These address a range of auditory music skills, challenging for most young or non-musicians.

Three minor caveats: First, the activities in the program can be accessed in any sequence, rather in a progression from simple to more difficult -- even though there is a significant variation in the difficulty level of the activities. This makes learning more of a challenge. Second, some of the point and click icons take the user to activities that require reading -- not a problem, unless you plan on giving the program to a pre-reader. Finally, although the program remembers where the user left off, it cannot keep track of multiple players' progress -- a drawback for school or multi-child family use.

Kid Appeal

Our young testers found much more to like in this program than in the earlier version -- simply because there was more material available to like. The additional activities increased the time they spent with the program, both initially, and in repeat usage.

Ease of Use / Install

Installation was simple on our test Windows ME machines, but took a few minutes, because of the size of the program (it requires at least 223.2 MB of disk space). With this greater size, however, comes a vastly improved audio library. Synthesized music has been replaced by orchestral versions that sound good even on small computer speakers.

Program use and navigation remain largely intuitive. Our young testers (ages 5 and 12) had no difficulty finding their way around the program. In addition, the screen frequently displays both a helpful "hint" button, and a "help" button, in case there are questions.

Best for... / Bottom-Line

The Nutcracker Music Game is a unique introduction to music program. It would make a good stocking-stuffer or birthday present for parents who enjoy music to give to their young children, and for children who are already demonstrating an interest in music.

See SuperKids' comparisons with other music software titles, and the Buyers Guide for current market prices of the PC and Mac (coming in early 2003) versions.

System Requirements
PC: Windows 98 or later, Pentium 360MHz or faster cpu, 250 MB hard drive space, 64 MB RAM .

Reviewed on:
-     Pentium III - 750 running Windows ME, with 128MB RAM and 24x - CD-ROM
return to top of page

Go to: About SuperKids Educational Software Review
Questions or comments regarding this site?
Copyright © 1998-2021 Knowledge Share LLC. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy